This list is subject to change at the Director's discretion. Last updated Thursday, January 31st
| Character | Age of Character | Description | Actor's age range for consideration | Strong Singer? | Strong Dancer? | Flies? |
| Peter Pan | 12 or 13 | Cocky, "ageless", pre-adolescent Boy with a magical innocence. | Director is open | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Wendy Darling | 13 or 14 | Graceful, refined girl with maternal instincts. | 12 - 16 years | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| John Darling | 12 | John is the middle Darling child. He is a rather serious, bespectacled boy | 10 - 14 years | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Michael Darling | 8 or 9 | Sweet, bubbly, a likeable boy, full of fun. | 8 - 11 years | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Liza (the maid) | Adult 20's | The Darlings' maid servant. | Adult 20's | | Yes | |
| Nana (the Dog) | | The Darlings' dog who is also the nanny for the children. | | | Yes | |
| Mrs.Darling | Adult 30's to 40's | Mother of the Darling children - a proper English Lady. | Adult | Yes | | |
| Mr. Darling | Adult 30's to 40's | Father of the Darling children. A childish man, he is rather brusque to his children and Nana. Must have good Comedic Skills | Adult | | | |
| Lion | | Dancing lion. | Director is open | | Yes | |
| Kangaroo | | Dancing Kangaroo | Director is open | | Yes | |
| Ostrich | | Dancing Ostrich | Director is open | | Yes | |
| Slightly | | Lost Boy -Conceited, knows very little but considers himself knowledgeable about most things. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Tootles | 12 or 13 | The leader of the Lost Boys in Peter’s absence. Rather simple but he has a good heart. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Curly | | Lost Boy - Curly haired (hence name). Rather timid but loyal. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Nibs | | Lost Boy - Extremely jovial, everything is a laugh and he has a great time. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| 1st Twin | | Lost Boy -One of identical twins. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| 2nd Twin | | Lost Boy -One of identical twins. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Captain Hook | Adult 30's to 40's | Captain of the pirates. Must have good comedic skills as well as able to portray a dangerous disposition. Stage fighting skills a plus | Adult | Yes | | |
| Smee | Adult 50's - 60's | An oddly genial oldish pirate, slightly cartoonesque, grey haired and a little pair of spectacles at the end of his nose. Good comedic skills. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Crocodile | | Menacing stalking croc. (No speaking) | Director is open | | Yes | |
| Tiger Lily | 13 to 15 | Good friend to Peter Pan - brave, loyal and strong. | 12 to 16 years old | Yes | Yes | |
| Starkey | | Pirate - comedic role. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Cecco | | Tall, manly pirate. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Noodler | | Pirate - comedic role. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Mullins | | Pirate - comedic role. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Jukes | | Medium height, tough guy, tattooed, don’t meet him in a dark alley. | Director is open | Yes | | |
| Wendy Grown-up | Adult 20's | Wendy as an adult with a child of her own. | Adult | | | |
| Jane | | Wendy's daughter. Like Wendy in many ways. | 10 - 14 years old | Yes | | Yes |
| Tinkerbell | Ageless | Mischievous fairy - loves and protects Peter Pan. | young looking | | Yes | Yes |
| Indians | | | | | Yes | 2 will fly |
| Lost Boys | | | | | | |
| Pirates | | | | | | 2 will fly |
